XML Key Management Services WG

DRAFT 8 June 2004 XKMS Teleconference Minutes
Chairs: Stephen Farrell, Shivaram Mysore
Note Takers: Stephen Farrell

Participants

• Stephen Farrell
• Guillermo Alvaro
• Tommy Lindberg
• Jose Kahan
• Ed Simon
• Roland Lockhart
• Merlin Hughes
• Pete Wenzel

Regrets

• Shivaram Mysore

Agenda

• Announcements
• Review last telecon AIs
• Interop Matrix
• AOB

Minutes

In the last telecon we had the following AIs which are still carried forward:

1. AI: Tommy will host a XKMS service endpoint for tests - date TBD. See below.
2. AI: Stephen will update the participant list - still OPEN (will do it soon - promise:-) CLOSED.
3. AI: Jose ask QA group about our current proposal still OPEN
4. Pete: How about including details about which implementations have worked against one another. AI: Guillermo. Still OPEN.
5. AI: ALL suggest possible events/venues for doing face-to-face interop testing within the next six months. Post suggestions to the list. Leave OPEN.
6. AI: Stephen/Shivaram will hassle (off-list) those who've said they'll write code to see where they're at. CLOSED.

Discussion:

• Tommy is now ready to put up X-KISS service sometime this week, incl. 2-phase and asychronous. Populated with test certs. Asynch. is handled manually, incl. notification. Certs etc. are as in sample set. Includes SOAP 1.1 and 1.2, Maybe HTTP later. Stuff that should work has been tested much more than failure cases. SOAP 1.2 endpoint testing in early days. If you're using this try to be nice to it for a while until Tommy gets more failure cases tested.
• Tommy also has the "toolkit" part of X-KRSS done-ish and can put up after his X-KISS service stabilises.
• Ed is interested in interop matrix xml procedures etc. and
• Merlin: Interop scenarios which provide reasonable coverage
• Guillermo: described process of producing latest matrix.

  Things to add:

  • Implementation/implementation part of the matrix
  • Scenarios are the right level of detail there
  • AI: All implementers: check the interop matrix as-is and send comments to list
  • AI: All implementers: check the column header for you is correct and send changes to Guillermo
• Scenarios:
  • AI: All implementers: send suggestions for outline scenarios to list in next two weeks
  • AI: Guillermo - send draft basic locate/validate scenario to list
• AI: Jose - turn Guillermo's XML into an on-line questionaire
• AI: Ed - Send links to what WS-Security did
• Roland has posted some sample way back and is in the process of updating to use the new samples and will re-send.

Next Telecon

• Next Telecon
• Date: June 22, 2004; Time - 8:30AM - 9:30AM PST, 11:30AM - 12:30PM EST; 4:20pm Dublin; check time for your local area here
• Agenda: Interop scenario list agreement, filling in the matrix and issues arising.